🗑️ The original repository has been deleted or made private. This page is an archival snapshot from indexing time; the install command may no longer work.

dsh-critique-loop

DeepSeek Harness plugin: forces one critique-and-improve round after each completed turn.

Ecosystem appAI ModelsCode review

Verification

L5 · Ecosystem app

Risk

Out of scope

Health

Stable

Trust

Gold

Install verification: Ecosystem app: not installed via dsh plugin add, so the L1-L5 plugin install-verification ladder does not apply; the security scan still runs.Install verification details →

What it doesAI

Adds a forced critique-and-improve round after every completed turn in DeepSeek Harness to enhance output quality.

Automatically applies a critique loop after each turn
Uses self-review to refine AI-generated outputs
Integrates into DeepSeek Harness plugin ecosystem

aiAIcode-reviewAI

Capability tags are AI-inferred or rule-extracted from the README (see badge) — vocabulary-limited, not install-verified. AI = inferred; README = literal keyword from the readme.

Installation

GitHub repository

Ecosystem apps are not installable via dsh plugin add: desktop / web shells install or deploy through their own release channel (GitHub Releases or the project site).

The level reads L5 · Ecosystem plugin / L5 · Ecosystem app per the three-way classification (the L1-L5 ladder does not rate them); the security scan still runs.

Verification & Compatibility◼ Ecosystem app

Grouped by plugin version: each card lists the dsh versions actually tested against that artifact version and their install verdicts (L5 wins). Untested combinations are omitted — absence means untested, never assumed compatible. L1–L3 are a plugin-level static archive (independent of the dsh version — the same verdict on every dsh row): they sit in each row's level grid next to L4/L5, marked "static", while their evidence is stored once per plugin inside that row's "checks & evidence" instead of being duplicated per version.

External credentials (plugin-level): none detected

Install compatibility matrix (rows = plugin versions〔latest 5〕, columns = dsh versions〔latest 5〕)

◼ Ecosystem app

At-a-glance → evidence in the cards below

plugin ＼ dsh	dsh 0.2.0-rc.1	dsh 0.1.7-rc.2	dsh 0.1.7-rc.1	dsh 0.1.7-alpha.2	dsh 0.1.6-alpha.2
d88166	◼	◼	◼	◼	◼

Install compatibility (by plugin version, dsh versions within)

Legend:✓ L5 runtime verified○ ecosystem plugin◼ ecosystem app✗ failed

d88166github✓ 3 runtime-verified◼ 9 ecosystem app2026-10-05

https://github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop

◼dsh 0.2.0-rc.12026-09-29Ecosystem app

Environment & artifact

• Node.js: v24.14.0
• DSH: 0.2.0-rc.1
• Plugin artifact: github · https://github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop (version unstated)

Levels (L1–L3 plugin-level static archive · L4/L5 newest real verdicts for this combination)

L1 static

Passed

L2 static

Passed

L3 static

Passed

L4 sandbox

Unknown

L5 runtime

Not tested

Ecosystem app: not installed via `dsh plugin add` (desktop / web shell) and no install verdict was produced — it ships through its own release channel and the L1-L5 ladder does not rate it (shown as L5 · ecosystem app)

Ecosystem app

ID: dsh-critique-loop@d88166@dsh0.2.0-rc.1 · profile: l4-sandbox

Issued: 2026-09-29 · expires: 2026-10-06

View checks & evidence

L1 · Found✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L1.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L2 · Structured✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L2.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L3 · Install spec✓ Passed

Install command parsedL3.1_INSTALL_COMMAND_PARSED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: install spec parse · Captured 2026-09-30

DSH version declaredL3.2_DSH_VERSION_DECLARED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: DSH version declaration · Captured 2026-09-30

L4 · Install tested? Unknown

Sandbox install verdictL4_0_SANDBOX? Unknown

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-09-29

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · channel GitHub source · outcome unknown

L5 · Run tested– Not tested

This level was not executed in this scan.

L1–L3 are plugin-level static conclusions (baseline, identical across dsh versions): evidence is stored once per plugin.

◼dsh 0.1.7-rc.22026-09-28Ecosystem app

Environment & artifact

• Node.js: v24.14.0
• DSH: 0.1.7-rc.2
• Plugin artifact: github · https://github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop (version unstated)

Levels (L1–L3 plugin-level static archive · L4/L5 newest real verdicts for this combination)

L1 static

Passed

L2 static

Passed

L3 static

Passed

L4 sandbox

Unknown

L5 runtime

Not tested

Ecosystem app

ID: dsh-critique-loop@d88166@dsh0.1.7-rc.2 · profile: l4-sandbox

Issued: 2026-09-28 · expires: 2026-10-05

View checks & evidence

L1 · Found✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L1.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L2 · Structured✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L2.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L3 · Install spec✓ Passed

Install command parsedL3.1_INSTALL_COMMAND_PARSED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: install spec parse · Captured 2026-09-30

DSH version declaredL3.2_DSH_VERSION_DECLARED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: DSH version declaration · Captured 2026-09-30

L4 · Install tested? Unknown

Sandbox install verdictL4_0_SANDBOX? Unknown

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-09-28

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · channel GitHub source · outcome unknown

L5 · Run tested– Not tested

This level was not executed in this scan.

L1–L3 are plugin-level static conclusions (baseline, identical across dsh versions): evidence is stored once per plugin.

◼dsh 0.1.7-rc.12026-09-23Ecosystem app

Environment & artifact

• Node.js: v24.14.0
• DSH: 0.1.7-rc.1
• Plugin artifact: github · https://github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop (version unstated)

Levels (L1–L3 plugin-level static archive · L4/L5 newest real verdicts for this combination)

L1 static

Passed

L2 static

Passed

L3 static

Passed

L4 sandbox

Unknown

L5 runtime

Not tested

Ecosystem app

ID: dsh-critique-loop@d88166@dsh0.1.7-rc.1 · profile: l4-sandbox

Issued: 2026-09-23 · expires: 2026-09-30

View checks & evidence

L1 · Found✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L1.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L2 · Structured✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L2.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L3 · Install spec✓ Passed

Install command parsedL3.1_INSTALL_COMMAND_PARSED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: install spec parse · Captured 2026-09-30

DSH version declaredL3.2_DSH_VERSION_DECLARED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: DSH version declaration · Captured 2026-09-30

L4 · Install tested? Unknown

Sandbox install verdictL4_0_SANDBOX? Unknown

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-09-23

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · channel GitHub source · outcome unknown

L5 · Run tested– Not tested

This level was not executed in this scan.

L1–L3 are plugin-level static conclusions (baseline, identical across dsh versions): evidence is stored once per plugin.

◼dsh 0.1.7-alpha.22026-09-23Ecosystem app

Environment & artifact

• Node.js: v24.14.0
• DSH: 0.1.7-alpha.2
• Plugin artifact: github · https://github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop (version unstated)

Levels (L1–L3 plugin-level static archive · L4/L5 newest real verdicts for this combination)

L1 static

Passed

L2 static

Passed

L3 static

Passed

L4 sandbox

Unknown

L5 runtime

Not tested

Ecosystem app

ID: dsh-critique-loop@d88166@dsh0.1.7-alpha.2 · profile: l4-sandbox

Issued: 2026-09-23 · expires: 2026-09-30

View checks & evidence

L1 · Found✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L1.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L2 · Structured✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L2.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L3 · Install spec✓ Passed

Install command parsedL3.1_INSTALL_COMMAND_PARSED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: install spec parse · Captured 2026-09-30

DSH version declaredL3.2_DSH_VERSION_DECLARED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: DSH version declaration · Captured 2026-09-30

L4 · Install tested? Unknown

Sandbox install verdictL4_0_SANDBOX? Unknown

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-09-23

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · channel GitHub source · outcome unknown

L5 · Run tested– Not tested

This level was not executed in this scan.

L1–L3 are plugin-level static conclusions (baseline, identical across dsh versions): evidence is stored once per plugin.

◼dsh 0.1.6-alpha.22026-09-22Ecosystem app

Environment & artifact

• Node.js: v24.14.0
• DSH: 0.1.6-alpha.2
• Plugin artifact: github · https://github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop (version unstated)

Levels (L1–L3 plugin-level static archive · L4/L5 newest real verdicts for this combination)

L1 static

Passed

L2 static

Passed

L3 static

Passed

L4 sandbox

Unknown

L5 runtime

Not tested

Ecosystem app

ID: dsh-critique-loop@d88166@dsh0.1.6-alpha.2 · profile: l4-sandbox

Issued: 2026-09-22 · expires: 2026-09-29

View checks & evidence

L1 · Found✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L1.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L2 · Structured✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L2.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L3 · Install spec✓ Passed

Install command parsedL3.1_INSTALL_COMMAND_PARSED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: install spec parse · Captured 2026-09-30

DSH version declaredL3.2_DSH_VERSION_DECLARED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: DSH version declaration · Captured 2026-09-30

L4 · Install tested? Unknown

Sandbox install verdictL4_0_SANDBOX? Unknown

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-09-22

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · channel GitHub source · outcome unknown

L5 · Run tested– Not tested

This level was not executed in this scan.

L1–L3 are plugin-level static conclusions (baseline, identical across dsh versions): evidence is stored once per plugin.

◼dsh 0.1.6-alpha.12026-09-17Ecosystem app

Environment & artifact

• Node.js: v24.14.0
• DSH: 0.1.6-alpha.1
• Plugin artifact: github · https://github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop (version unstated)

Levels (L1–L3 plugin-level static archive · L4/L5 newest real verdicts for this combination)

L1 static

Passed

L2 static

Passed

L3 static

Passed

L4 sandbox

Unknown

L5 runtime

Not tested

Ecosystem app

ID: dsh-critique-loop@d88166@dsh0.1.6-alpha.1 · profile: l4-sandbox

Issued: 2026-09-17 · expires: 2026-09-24

View checks & evidence

L1 · Found✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L1.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L2 · Structured✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L2.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L3 · Install spec✓ Passed

Install command parsedL3.1_INSTALL_COMMAND_PARSED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: install spec parse · Captured 2026-09-30

DSH version declaredL3.2_DSH_VERSION_DECLARED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: DSH version declaration · Captured 2026-09-30

L4 · Install tested? Unknown

Sandbox install verdictL4_0_SANDBOX? Unknown

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-09-17

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · channel GitHub source · outcome unknown

L5 · Run tested– Not tested

This level was not executed in this scan.

L1–L3 are plugin-level static conclusions (baseline, identical across dsh versions): evidence is stored once per plugin.

◼dsh 0.1.5-rc.22026-09-13Ecosystem app

Environment & artifact

• Node.js: v24.14.0
• DSH: 0.1.5-rc.2
• Plugin artifact: github · https://github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop (version unstated)

Levels (L1–L3 plugin-level static archive · L4/L5 newest real verdicts for this combination)

L1 static

Passed

L2 static

Passed

L3 static

Passed

L4 sandbox

Unknown

L5 runtime

Not tested

Ecosystem app

ID: dsh-critique-loop@d88166@dsh0.1.5-rc.2 · profile: l4-sandbox

Issued: 2026-09-13 · expires: 2026-09-20

View checks & evidence

L1 · Found✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L1.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L2 · Structured✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L2.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L3 · Install spec✓ Passed

Install command parsedL3.1_INSTALL_COMMAND_PARSED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: install spec parse · Captured 2026-09-30

DSH version declaredL3.2_DSH_VERSION_DECLARED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: DSH version declaration · Captured 2026-09-30

L4 · Install tested? Unknown

Sandbox install verdictL4_0_SANDBOX? Unknown

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-09-13

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · channel GitHub source · outcome unknown

L5 · Run tested– Not tested

This level was not executed in this scan.

L1–L3 are plugin-level static conclusions (baseline, identical across dsh versions): evidence is stored once per plugin.

◼dsh 0.1.3-alpha.22026-09-08Ecosystem app

Environment & artifact

• Node.js: v24.14.0
• DSH: 0.1.3-alpha.2
• Plugin artifact: github · https://github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop (version unstated)

Levels (L1–L3 plugin-level static archive · L4/L5 newest real verdicts for this combination)

L1 static

Passed

L2 static

Passed

L3 static

Passed

L4 sandbox

Unknown

L5 runtime

Not tested

Ecosystem app

ID: dsh-critique-loop@d88166@dsh0.1.3-alpha.2 · profile: l4-sandbox

Issued: 2026-09-08 · expires: 2026-09-15

View checks & evidence

L1 · Found✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L1.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L2 · Structured✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L2.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L3 · Install spec✓ Passed

Install command parsedL3.1_INSTALL_COMMAND_PARSED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: install spec parse · Captured 2026-09-30

DSH version declaredL3.2_DSH_VERSION_DECLARED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: DSH version declaration · Captured 2026-09-30

L4 · Install tested? Unknown

Sandbox install verdictL4_0_SANDBOX? Unknown

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-09-08

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · channel GitHub source · outcome unknown

L5 · Run tested– Not tested

This level was not executed in this scan.

L1–L3 are plugin-level static conclusions (baseline, identical across dsh versions): evidence is stored once per plugin.

✓dsh 0.1.3-alpha.12026-09-07L5 · runtime verified

Environment & artifact

• Node.js: v24.14.0
• DSH: 0.1.3-alpha.1
• Plugin artifact: github · https://github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop (version unstated)

Levels (L1–L3 plugin-level static archive · L4/L5 newest real verdicts for this combination)

L1 static

Passed

L2 static

Passed

L3 static

Passed

L4 sandbox

Passed

L5 runtime

Passed

Install + runtime smoke verified in the dsh sandbox — installs and runs

L5 · runtime verified · valid for dsh 0.1.3-alpha.1

ID: dsh-critique-loop@d88166@dsh0.1.3-alpha.1 · profile: l3-fullscan

Issued: 2026-09-07 · expires: 2026-09-14

View checks & evidence

L1 · Found✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L1.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L2 · Structured✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L2.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L3 · Install spec✓ Passed

Install command parsedL3.1_INSTALL_COMMAND_PARSED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: install spec parse · Captured 2026-09-30

DSH version declaredL3.2_DSH_VERSION_DECLARED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: DSH version declaration · Captured 2026-09-30

L4 · Install tested✓ Passed

Install executed in confined sandboxL4.1_INSTALL_EXECUTED_CONFINED✓ Passed

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-09-06

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · channel GitHub source · outcome ran · exit 0

check took: 2.7s

Install succeededL4.2_INSTALL_SUCCESS✓ Passed

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-09-06

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · channel GitHub source · outcome ran · exit 0

check took: 2.7s

Installed artifact confirmedL4.3_ARTIFACT_CONFIRMED✓ Passed

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-09-06

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · channel GitHub source · outcome ran · exit 0

check took: 2.7s

L5 · Run tested✓ Passed

active in loader tree (151 entries)

Sandbox install passedL5.1_INSTALL_PASSED_SANDBOXED✓ Passed

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-09-06

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · install mode reused L4 scratch

check took: 67ms

Web boot readyL5.2_WEB_BOOT_READY✓ Passed

Source: DSH runtime · Method: web boot · Captured 2026-09-06

ready line dsh web: http://127.0.0.1:57812/?token=…

HTTP endpoint servedL5.3_HTTP_SERVED✓ Passed

Source: DSH runtime · Method: HTTP request · Captured 2026-09-06

path / · HTTP 200 · took 67ms

Plugin active in inventoryL5.4_PLUGIN_INVENTORY_ACTIVE✓ Passed

Source: DSH runtime · Method: plugin inventory query · Captured 2026-09-06

verdict active · entries 151

match: include:dsh-critique-loop · dsh-critique-loop · phase active

phases: active 123 · null 28

L1–L3 are plugin-level static conclusions (baseline, identical across dsh versions): evidence is stored once per plugin.

✓dsh 0.1.2-rc.12026-09-05L5 · runtime verified

Environment & artifact

• Node.js: v24.14.0
• DSH: 0.1.2-rc.1
• Plugin artifact: github · https://github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop#d88166

Levels (L1–L3 plugin-level static archive · L4/L5 newest real verdicts for this combination)

L1 static

Passed

L2 static

Passed

L3 static

Passed

L4 sandbox

Passed

L5 runtime

Passed

Install + runtime smoke verified in the dsh sandbox — installs and runs

L5 · runtime verified · valid for dsh 0.1.2-rc.1

ID: dsh-critique-loop@d88166@dsh0.1.2-rc.1 · profile: l3-fullscan

Issued: 2026-09-05 · expires: 2026-09-12

View checks & evidence

L1 · Found✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L1.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L2 · Structured✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L2.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L3 · Install spec✓ Passed

Install command parsedL3.1_INSTALL_COMMAND_PARSED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: install spec parse · Captured 2026-09-30

DSH version declaredL3.2_DSH_VERSION_DECLARED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: DSH version declaration · Captured 2026-09-30

L4 · Install tested✓ Passed

Install succeededL4.2_INSTALL_SUCCESS✓ Passed

L5 · Run tested✓ Passed

active in loader tree (150 entries)

Sandbox install passedL5.1_INSTALL_PASSED_SANDBOXED✓ Passed

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-09-04

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · install mode reused L4 scratch

check took: 24ms

Web boot readyL5.2_WEB_BOOT_READY✓ Passed

Source: DSH runtime · Method: web boot · Captured 2026-09-04

ready line dsh web: http://127.0.0.1:54838/?token=…

HTTP endpoint servedL5.3_HTTP_SERVED✓ Passed

Source: DSH runtime · Method: HTTP request · Captured 2026-09-04

path / · HTTP 200 · took 24ms

Plugin active in inventoryL5.4_PLUGIN_INVENTORY_ACTIVE✓ Passed

Source: DSH runtime · Method: plugin inventory query · Captured 2026-09-04

verdict active · entries 150

match: include:dsh-critique-loop · dsh-critique-loop · phase active

phases: active 122 · null 28

L1–L3 are plugin-level static conclusions (baseline, identical across dsh versions): evidence is stored once per plugin.

✓dsh 0.1.2-alpha.12026-09-06L5 · runtime verified

Environment & artifact

• Node.js: v24.14.0
• DSH: 0.1.2-alpha.1
• Plugin artifact: github · https://github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop (version unstated)

Levels (L1–L3 plugin-level static archive · L4/L5 newest real verdicts for this combination)

L1 static

Passed

L2 static

Passed

L3 static

Passed

L4 sandbox

Passed

L5 runtime

Passed

Install + runtime smoke verified in the dsh sandbox — installs and runs

L5 · runtime verified · valid for dsh 0.1.2-alpha.1

ID: dsh-critique-loop@d88166@dsh0.1.2-alpha.1 · profile: l3-fullscan

Issued: 2026-09-06 · expires: 2026-09-13

View checks & evidence

L1 · Found✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L1.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L2 · Structured✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L2.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L3 · Install spec✓ Passed

Install command parsedL3.1_INSTALL_COMMAND_PARSED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: install spec parse · Captured 2026-09-30

DSH version declaredL3.2_DSH_VERSION_DECLARED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: DSH version declaration · Captured 2026-09-30

L4 · Install tested✓ Passed

Install succeededL4.2_INSTALL_SUCCESS✓ Passed

L5 · Run tested✓ Passed

active in loader tree (149 entries)

Sandbox install passedL5.1_INSTALL_PASSED_SANDBOXED✓ Passed

check took: 111ms

Web boot readyL5.2_WEB_BOOT_READY✓ Passed

Source: DSH runtime · Method: web boot · Captured 2026-09-06

ready line dsh web: http://127.0.0.1:50473/?token=…

HTTP endpoint servedL5.3_HTTP_SERVED✓ Passed

Source: DSH runtime · Method: HTTP request · Captured 2026-09-06

path / · HTTP 200 · took 111ms

Plugin active in inventoryL5.4_PLUGIN_INVENTORY_ACTIVE✓ Passed

Source: DSH runtime · Method: plugin inventory query · Captured 2026-09-06

verdict active · entries 149

match: include:dsh-critique-loop · dsh-critique-loop · phase active

phases: active 122 · null 27

L1–L3 are plugin-level static conclusions (baseline, identical across dsh versions): evidence is stored once per plugin.

◼prehistory2026-10-05Ecosystem app

Environment & artifact

• Node.js: v24.14.0
• DSH: unknown
• Plugin artifact: github · https://github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop (version unstated)

Levels (L1–L3 plugin-level static archive · L4/L5 newest real verdicts for this combination)

L1 static

Passed

L2 static

Passed

L3 static

Passed

L4 sandbox

Unknown

L5 runtime

Not tested

Ecosystem app

ID: dsh-critique-loop@d88166@dshunknown · profile: l4-sandbox

Issued: 2026-10-05 · expires: 2026-10-12

View checks & evidence

L1 · Found✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L1.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L2 · Structured✓ Passed

Defaulted from L3L2.0_DEFAULTED_FROM_L3✓ Passed

defaulted to passed — L3 install spec passed (full-registry L3 sweep policy)

L3 · Install spec✓ Passed

Install command parsedL3.1_INSTALL_COMMAND_PARSED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: install spec parse · Captured 2026-09-30

DSH version declaredL3.2_DSH_VERSION_DECLARED✓ Passed

Source: registry verification · Method: DSH version declaration · Captured 2026-09-30

L4 · Install tested? Unknown

Sandbox install verdictL4_0_SANDBOX? Unknown

Source: Windows ACL sandbox · Method: sandbox install run · Captured 2026-10-05

spec github:Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop · channel GitHub source · outcome unknown

L5 · Run tested– Not tested

This level was not executed in this scan.

L1–L3 are plugin-level static conclusions (baseline, identical across dsh versions): evidence is stored once per plugin.

Author badges

Embed the official badges in your README to showcase security & install-test status:

Security Report

Two automated layers, neither a manual review: a static scan (per-plugin rule checks) and a model-driven dynamic security audit that covers only the subset static-flagged at warn or above and never executes plugin code.

dsh-critique-loopAutomated review · daily

Static low, dynamic no conclusion — stricter wins → overall low.

static low→dynamic no conclusion→overall low

0 critical·0 high

lowoverall · low

1static scan · vet primaryvet AST static analysis (npm artifact or git source)

Version binding

plugin versionv0.1.0dsh manifest

scanned version0.1.0git2026-10-07

current version0.1.0same version

vet verdictclean · git

Vet is an AST static scan (npm artifact or git source).

2dynamic auditmodel reads redacted source context · never executes plugin code

not in the dynamic queue (queue only covers plugins static-flagged at warn or above) — this does not mean the dynamic audit found it safe.

Rule: the dynamic audit can only raise risk, never lower it (raise-only, never an exemption); a wrong raise is withdrawn by human review and the tier falls back to the static verdict. Overall verdict = the stricter of the two layers.

Disclaimer: the static scan and the dynamic security audit are both automated analysis, not a security guarantee. Always review what you install.

Activity

Last commit 2026-09-01 · activity: Stable

• Repo created: 2026-09-01

• Stars: ★ 0 · Forks: 0

• Health: Stable — committed within 90 days

Source

GitHub: github.com/Milbaxter/dsh-critique-loop

Plugin notes

What is dsh-critique-loop?

dsh-critique-loop is an ecosystem app maintained by @Milbaxter, not a DSH plugin package — it cannot be installed via dsh plugin add; desktop / web shells ship through the project's own release channel. It is cataloged on dsh.so as a AI Models entry, with a public source repository and automated static security scan.

How do I install dsh-critique-loop?

This is an ecosystem app, not a plugin installable via dsh plugin add: desktop / web shells install or deploy through their own release channel. Its level reads L5 · Ecosystem app; the security scan still runs.

How does the security scan relate to a manual audit?

Both layers are automated, not a manual audit: the static scan is heuristic analysis of the repository source (it can produce false positives and miss context), and the dynamic security audit has a model read the harvested source context with secret files stripped and content redacted inline — plugin code is never executed. The dynamic audit only covers plugins static-flagged at warn or above, and its conclusion can only raise the combined verdict, never exempt it. Neither layer is a manual security audit or an endorsement; before using a plugin, review the repository and installed permissions, and combine both with the verification level (L4/L5) and health signals.

"DeepSeek Harness (dsh) is an open-source agent harness developed by DeepSeek AI. It uses an architecture where everything is a plugin, and is powered by Cordis."
— DeepSeek Harness README

Sources: GitHub repository · DeepSeek Harness README · security scan data · Maintained by dsh.so · Last updated 2026-09-01

dsh-critique-loop

What it doesAI

Installation

Verification & Compatibility◼ Ecosystem app

Author badges

Security Report

Activity

Source

Author README